A Comparative Study between the Traditional Ratings and Real Acoustical Properties of Walnut Wood (Juglans regia) used in Santur Making*

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Master Degree in Engineering in Wood and Paper Science Technology, faculty of Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

2 Associate Professor, Department of Wood Sicence and Technology, Faculty of Natural Resources, , University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

3 PhD Holder in Mechanic of Tree and Wood, University of Montpellier II, Montpellier, France

4 Resercher in Civil Engineering, Department of Mechanic of tree and wood, University of Montpellier II, Montpellier, France.

Abstract

Abstract:
For many years, the wood of walnut tree (Juglans regia) has been used for making Santur. Even though artisans have their own divers’ ideas about this species’ features; until now there has been no scientific data to support them. In Santur’s case specially, differently cut surface plates can be formed into final instrument. Besides, some steam treatments, which supposedly improve the final sound quality, are common for preparing the raw material. Their true efficiency is also unknown. In this study, specimens from Sanoor’s surface plates with different traditional grading were collected from ateliers of two professional instrument makers and their real vibrational properties were measured and compared. Different cutting plans, visual characteristics, the types of pretreatments involved as well as the sample’s age and conditions were the basis of grading according to artisans. Samples were dried and stabilized in a climatic chamber before being tested for their vibrational qualities. The vibration test was done using a non contact free-free bar bending method. The frequency sweep was between 100 and 500 Hz and both specific elastic modulus (E/ρ) – from the first frequency resonance using Euler-Bernoulli method– and damping coefficient (tanδ) –using bandwidth at the half power– were calculated. Walnut wood had the basic characteristics of chordophones related species: high specific modulus and comparatively low damping coefficient. No statistically significant difference was observed between the four obtained mechanical factors (i.e. Density, Young modulus, specific modulus and damping) based on the wood conditions (Heartwood or sapwood). However the traditional grading was related to the measured characteristics. The best graded specimens had both higher densities and Young moduli. In all specimens the standard decreasing relation between damping coefficient and specific modulus was observed. This verified the trustworthiness of the calculated data. As a general fact, the results of acoustical tests were in harmony with the grading. This means that the better graded samples had relatively higher specific moduli and lower damping coefficients. The situation was vice versa for the lowest grades. The line separating the best and the worst graded specimens was very clear, on the other hand middle range grades borderlines were vague, meaning all the measured factors were almost in the same range. This indicated the importance of artisanal cut, wood color and design in traditional grading: one acoustically valuable specimen could be cast aside just because it is not properly cut. Steaming as a commonly done traditional pretreatment had improving effects on the wood’s final characteristics: it apparently caused the specimen properties to get closer to the best graded ones. An old wood can also be considered a treated specimen, as aging can also be done artificially (by the hands of the craftsmen through leaving the wood untouched for years before beginning the process of fabrication) or naturally (as in direct using of an old tree). Walnut aged specimen, also demonstrated nearly the best mechanical features, validating the choice of the instrument makers in preferring the aged wood over the freshly cut one. In conclusion, in the case of Santur, a significant coherence between artisanal experimental knowledge and scientific data was observed

Keywords

Full Text

.

References

Aramaki, M, Baillères, H, Brancheriau, L, Kronland-Martinet, R, Ystad, S(2007), Sound quality assessment of wood for xylophone bars, Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 121,p13.
 
Brancheriau, L, Baillères, H, Détienne, P, Gril, J, Kronland, R(2006), Key signal and wood anatomy parameters related to the acoustic quality of wood for xylophone-type percussion instruments, Journal of Wood Science, vol 52,3,p3.
 
Bremaud, I(2006), PhD thesis, Diversity of woods used or usable in musical instruments making (In French), University of Montpellier II, Montpellier, France, p302.
 
Bremaud, I(2012), Acoustical properties of wood in string instruments, soundboards and tuned idiophones: biological and cultural diversity, J Acoust Soc Am, vol 131, 1, p11.
 
Bucur, V(2006), Acoustics of wood, Springer, Germany.
 
Fletcher, N.H, Rossing, T.D(1998), The physics of musical instruments, Springer, Germany.
 
Gerhards, C.C(1982), Effect of moisture content and temperature on the mechanical properties of wood: an analysis of immediate effects, Wood Fiber, vol 14, p32.
 
Gril, J, Bremaud, I(2007), Interest of some local  secondary species for instrunebt making, (in French),  The conference of better evaluation of secondary species for artisanal use, 7 June, Montpellier, France.
 
Haines, D.W(2000), The essential mechanical properties of wood prepared for musical instruments, Catgut Acoustical Society Journal, vol 4(two (series II)), p12.
 
Kubojima, Y, Suzuki, Y, Tonosaki, M(2005), Vibrational properties of green wood in high-temperature water vapor, Holzforschung, vol 59, 4, p4.
 
Noguchi, T, Obataya, E, Ando, K(2011), Effects of ageing on the vibrational properties of akamatsu (Pinus densiflora) wood, Wood Culture and Science, Kyoto, Japan.
 
Ono, T, Norimoto, M(1983), Study on Young's modulus and internal friction of wood in relation to the evaluation of wood for musical instruments, Jpn J Appl Phys, vol 22, p3.
 
Ono, T, Norimoto, M(1984), On physical criteria for the selection of wood for soundboards of musical instruments, Rheol Acta, vol 23, p4.
 
Roohnia,  M, Hashemi-dizaji, S.F, Brancheriau, L, Tajdini, A, Hemmasi, A.M, Manouchehri, N (2011), Effect of soaking process in water on the acoustical quality of wood for traditional musical instruments, Bioresources, vol 6, 2, p10.
Se Golpayegani, A, Brémaud, I, Gril, J, Thévenon, M.F, Arnould, O, Pourtahmasi, K(2011), Effect of extractions on dynamic mechanical properties of white mulberry (Morus alba L.), J wood Sci, vol 58, 2, DOI: 10.1007/s10086-011-1225-7.
 
Wegst, U(2006), Wood for sound, American Journal of Botany, vol 93, 10, p9.
 
Yoshikawa, S(2007), Acoustical classification of woods for string instruments, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, vol 122, p5.
Journal of Fine Arts: Performing Arts & Music
Volume 18, Issue 1 - Serial Number 1
February 2014
Pages 23-32

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics